All posts filed under: Rate the dress

Rate the Dress Mid-Century Maybe-Maternity

Today’s Rate the Dress pick was chosen because it’s a garment that has fascinated me for years. There are so many mid-century gowns that museums claim were maternity dresses, where I really don’t see it. It’s just a wrapper, or a dress in a larger size, or… The Met doesn’t claim that this dress dress was a maternity dress, but gosh, that waistline is high… Last week: an 1780s gown with an embroidered hem Wow! I thought last week’s dress was very pretty indeed, but I didn’t expect the outpouring of adoration that it received! You loved every detail, from the not-quite symmetrical embroidery, to the vandyked bodice trim. You just wanted to see it fully styled, with fichu and bows. The Total: 9.7 In Rate the Dress, anything about a 9.5 is as close to perfection as you can get! This week:  a very short-waisted ca. 1855 afternoon dress The Met’s description of this afternoon dress is very simple and generic, and makes no mention of how unusually high the waist of this dress …

Robe à l’anglaise ca. 1780 From the Galleria del Costume di Palazzo Pitti via Europeana Fashion

Rate the Dress: Georgian embroidery

Last week I drove from Wellington to Gisborne, 9 hours drive up the eastern coast of North Island, and back, and was reminded again how stunningly gorgeous New Zealand is. The country is currently bedecked in autumnal splendour: end of season flax flowers standing in stark black against the sky, pampas grasses blushing pink and champagne and silvery lavender, the occasional stands of deciduous trees in a blaze of colour, meadows returning to lush green with the resumption of rain, and sudden storms bringing exhilarating downpours and rainbows at the end. So my Rate the Dress pick for this week comes in all these colours: though it’s not a style of dress that was ever worn in New Zealand! Plus, the totals are (finally) in for the feather bedecked confection of the week before! Last week: an 1870s dress in pale pink and ivory, with historical touches The general reaction to last week’s dress was that it just didn’t quite get the balance right. Something was missing, or was there that shouldn’t be, for almost …

Rate the Dress: Pale Pink Restrained Historicism

Last week’s rate the dress was almost universally unpopular, and also quite confusing: what colour was it? Gold? Green? Grey-faune as the auction listing gave it? To simplify the confusion, this week I’ve picked a dress in a very simple colour. It’s pale pink. I don’t think anyone is going to argue with that! (We could get quite detailed about the exact hue though…cherry blossom? Blush? ) Last week: an 1876 reception or day dress said to have been worn by Empress Eugenie  I’m actually away for the next week, rusticating in the glorious rural swathes of New Zealand, away from reliable internet. So I haven’t tallied the votes yet. But I can tell you what the overall verdict is going to be: not good. Update: Now with the Total! : 4.9 out of 10 With ratings ranging from 1 to 9.5, I find it very satisfying that the aggregate total is exactly at the mid point! This week: an 1870s gown with historically inspired details. This week I’m sticking with the same timeperiod as last week, …